Skip to main content

What is a Passive Voice Sentence?

The topic of passive sentences naturally leads onto participles. As such the next two post form a unit and should be read together.
Active & Passive voice sentences
Now so far on this blog, we have dealt only with active sentences – where subject performs an action on some target object.

With a passive sentence (sometimes called the passive voice) the grammatical subject  gets something done to them!

Compare:
   
  Active voice   Passive voice
Semantic: agent   patient   patient   agent
Grammatic: subject transitive object   subject intransitive instrument
  The dog chases the cat   The cat is chased by the dog
Notice:
the semantic terms: agent - patient; and
the grammatic terms: subject - object.
In the active sentence above, the subject of the verb is the dog! And this is also the agent of the action. While the object of the verb is the cat.
In the passive sentence, the subject of the verb is the cat! And the agent of the action, in both instances is the dog.

In active sentences the meanings of subject - object and agent - patient overlap, and indeed, many grammar guides use them interchangeably. However, it is only with passive sentences that the difference becomes clear.
The agent is always the entity doing the action - here it is the dog, the one doing the chasing.
The patient (or target) is the entity acted upon - this is the cat, the one being chased.
And these are actually different notions from the grammatical terms: subject and object.
The grammatical subject is the noun (or phrase) with which the verb agrees in person and number. It relates to the syntax of the verb...

Notice how the object of the active sentence becomes the subject of the passive sentence. While the agent remains the same in both. But, in a passive sentence, the agent is relegated to a prepositional phrase (in instrumental), and its inclusion is optional.

Because of this, it often better to adopt the agent - patient terminology when dealing with passive sentences in order to avoid any confusion.

Note also, that the verb chased is actually a past participle which is accompanied by the auxiliary verb is (a form of 'to be'). In English, the passive voice is always marked by an auxilary verb and a past participle.

Here's a video tutorial exploring:

English: Active & Passive Voice Rules :Language Basics

What is the passive voice? This tutorial looks at how English uses the passive voice and analyses the structure of active and passive sentences. It covers grammatical terms like subject & object as we...

Passive Voice in Pali

In Pali, the subject of a passive verb (i.e. the patient of the action), is denoted by the nominative case, and any agent will be in instrumental (or sometime genitive). It is rare for an auxiliary to be present so one has to be added by the translator.
Unlike English, there are two ways of forming a passive sentence in Pali. The verb can be either:
  1. a past participle, or
  2. a passive indicate

1. with a Past Participle

Grammar guides often label the past participle as the Past Passive Participle as they are predominantly used in passive sentences.
a-daṇḍena a-satthena nāgo danto mahesinā
instr instr nom nom instr
m m m m m
sgl sgl sgl sgl sgl
      past part.  
by no stick by no knife the elephant trained by the great sage
without a stick or knife, the elephant (is) trained by the great sage
the negation (a-) prefixed to an instrumental can be rendered ‘without’ (by-no).
The past participle. although called Past, can actually be used to express any time period: past, present or future. For more see the section on Aspect below...

2. with a Passive indicative stem

Though not frequent, Pali has a class of verbs that are specifically passive in meaning. These are a secondary derivative and are sometimes called passive indicatives. They are created from verb roots or the present stem by adding the suffix -(i)ya- (sometimes with 'i' connecting).
base + (i)ya + personal endings
√kar + īya + ti => kariyati (is done)
√pahā + īya + ti => pahīyati (is given up)
I think all tense endings can be applied - present endings shown.

The ‘y’ of the ‘-ya’ often assimilates and disappears, sometimes resulting in a consonant in the base verb being doubled.
labha + ya + ti => labbhati
 √vac + ya + ti => vuccati
As such they can be hard to spot. For more detail on formation see the post Secondary verb derivation and also the Assimilation of y.

When translating passive verbs, because in English the passive is always expressed by an auxiliary + past participle, this general guide can be followed where the auxiliary expresses the required tense.
  • passive verb in present: 'is/are' + past participle
  • passive verb in past:  'was/were' + past participle
  • passive verb in future: 'will be' + past participle

Some examples:
kicchena labbhati
adv pres, pass
   
  sgl
  3rd pers
with difficulty to be obtained
...(it) is obtained with difficulty
na candim-asūriyā paññāyanti
indec nom pres, pass
  f  
  pl pl
    3rd pers
not sun & moon (made) evident
the sun & moon are not evident
katamesaṃ dhammānaṃ uppādo paññāyissati ?
dat/gen dat/gen nom fut, pass
m m m  
pl pl sgl sgl
pn-intg     3rd pers
(of) which phenomena arising, birth will be (made) evident
of which phenomena will arising be evident?
The patient/subject of the passive verb is always in nominative!

The following video tutorial goes into some more detail.

Passive Voice in Pāli | Learn Pali Language #26

In this second part to the passive voice, we look at two ways of creating the passive voice in a Pali sentence. We see how passive indicative verbs are formed and this is contrasted with the use of pa...

Tense, Aspect & mood vs Voice

I find much of the terminology around passive sentences and verb tense, mood, & aspects barely comprehensible and confusing. So I will spend some time and explain these terms in English grammar. There is also an excellent article on English verb forms here.

Verb principal parts

As a carry-over from Latin, an English verbs can be be said to have 4 principal forms : the simple, the past and two participles.  Consider the verbs 'to write' & ‘to go’:
simple present simple past present participle past participle
write wrote writing written
go went going gone

Besides the simple present and past there are the participle forms. In English, there are two types of participle traditionally called the present participle (forms such as going, singing and raising) and the past participle (forms such as gone, sung and raised).  Participles are a type of cross between a verb and an adjective. They can qualify other nouns: 'the flying kite' or act as a verb: 'I am writing a letter'. When acting as a verb in English they require another verb (an auxiliary or helping verb) to fully express meaning; compare: 'I go', 'I went',   with   'I have gone' &  'I am going'..

Now although they are called present & past participles, in fact they can be employed to express any the tense! To understand this let's dig into English tenses.

Verb Tense, Aspect & Mood/Mode 

In English grammar, the word tense usually refers to a combination of both time period and aspect - and also sometimes mood
  • The verb tense indicates the time at which the action of the verb takes place – past, present or future.
  • The aspect of a verb tells us the degree to which it is completed. There are continuous (also called progressive or imperfect) aspects that tell us the action is in progress; there are perfect aspects that tell us the action is complete and of continuing relevance, and there are simple aspects that are just that – simple.
  • Verb mood or mode  is the purpose of the sentence in which a verb is used. In Pali, the indicative mood is used to make a statement. The optative mood expresses desires or wishes. And the conditional mood (also subjunctive) is for sentences that pose potential or hypothetical scenarios  While the imperative expresses commands and requests - I won’t include it here. 
Pali like many Proto-Indo-European languages makes no division between tense and mode and many guides refer to them as the same thing.
  Tenses & modes
Mood:
Indicative Conditional Optative
Aspects:
Present Past Future    
Simple go(es) went will go would go may go
Progressive (imperfect) am/is/are going was/were going will be going would be going may be going
Perfect have/has gone had gone will have gone would have gone may have gone
Perfect-
progressive
have/has been going had been going will have been going would have
been going
may have
been going

And so we get terms like present progressive 'I am going', future perfect-progressive 'I will have been going' etc. The past perfect 'I had gone' is sometimes called the pluperfect. I include all this because the grammar guides are packed with this jargon, often mixing grammatical terms of English with those of Latin.

English: 12 Tenses: Time vs Aspect :Language Basics

In this tutorial, we look at the 12 tenses in English as combinations of place in Time vs Aspect or completion. There are with explanations including time-lines and formulas. 

Here’s a handy app to conjugate English verbs.

Now notice how the various tense - aspect combinations beyond the simple present and past are formed by
  • perfect:  auxiliary + past participle,
  • progressive: auxiliary + present participle,
Though the participles are called past and present participles they are employed to express all the tenses!

Some authors refer to participles as future perfect etc. but really I think in English it is the combination of auxiliary + verb/participle that creates the tense-aspect.

Tense vs Passive constructions

Now just to make this all this a bit more confusing; all the tense-aspect combinations expressed above can be cast into the passive voice!

In English this is done by making the patient into the subject and using a past participle with an auxiliary verb. You can tell if a sentence is in passive voice by adding an agent: by me; at the end. If the sentence still makes sense, it's passive.
Tense-aspect Active Passive
present simple I write a blog. A blog is written (by me).
present continuous I am writing a blog. A blog is being written (by me).
past simple I wrote a blog. A blog was written (by me).
past continuous I was writing a blog. A blog was being written (by me).
present perfect I have written a blog. A blog has been written (by me).
pres. perf. continuous I have been writing a blog. A blog has been being written (by me).
past perfect I had written a blog. A blog had been written (by me).
future simple I will write a blog. A blog will be written (by me).
future perfect I will have written a blog. A blog will have been written (by me).
Notice how the passive is always expressed in English by:
passive:       auxiliaries + past participle.

Participles often get labelled as ‘active’ and ‘passive’ and this relates to the form of the participle - but not necessarily to the voice of the sentence!
However in Pali, participles and even verbs can be made passive due to their form alone!

So in the next post we'll look at Participles in Pali.

More posts

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is Pali Language? A little history

In all these grammar tutorials we have never stopped to ask: What is Pali?” “What does the word mean?” “What are the origins of Pali? And this is what we will investigate in this post.... What is Pali & Who Speaks it? Well, let's get the obvious answer out of the way: Pali is an ancient Middle Indo-Aryan language native to the Indian subcontinent. It is widely studied because it is the language, in which, the scriptures of Theravada school of Buddhism - or Tipiṭaka - have been preserved and passed down. True. Today Pali is studied mainly to gain access to Theravada Buddhist scriptures, and is frequently chanted in a ritual context. But when we say a ' language ', most languages are named either after a population or a region, and we have no evidence of a region called Pali or even a population of Pali speakers... Along side this, nowhere in the Pali canon itself is there a mention of a language called Pali!

Sutta Number to PTS reference converter

Easily look up PTS references in the Sutta Piṭaka. [New expanded coverage tables. Includes alternate numbering. Search accepts space, comma or period separated numbers, case insensitive, diacritic insensitive.] Quick Jump Table   PTS Vol Dīgha Nikāya (DN) D i , D ii , D iii Majjhima Nikāya (MN)   M i , M ii , M iii Saṁyutta Nikāya (SN) S i , S ii , S iii , S iv , S v Aṅguttara Nikāya (AN)   A i , A ii , A iii , A iv , A v Go to Khuddaka Nikaya (KN) ( New! KN ref converter ) Use the quick jump table above; Note: For Vol. i of SN, there are two sets of PTS page numbers for each sutta. This is because the L. Feer editions differs from Somaratne 1999. Or type a Sutta number or name into the search boxes below to search that column of the table!

Learn Pali: Best way to start? 5 Tips to make it easy

Once people have answered the question: "Why learn Pali?" The next query is: "How do I learn Pali?" Here’s the way I suggest you begin with your study of Pali. Build foundations for language learning Start at the right level Stick with it Build vocabulary Make use of the Pali language tools 1 Build foundations for language learning One thing that you really should have before beginning to learn Pali is a basic understanding of general grammatical terms and concepts. Many of the Pali language grammar guides seem to assume you have studied Sanskrit or Latin before. If you haven’t, and you really don’t know the difference between a subject and an object, or the meanings of such terms as nouns, verbs, adjectives, pronouns, prepositions, or declension and conjugation - then perhaps you should spend some time studying English grammar. I found that even though I'm a native English sp

Pali Alphabet & using the PED Dictionary

What is the Pali Alphabet? How is it arranged? How do you use a Pali dictionary? Well, the first thing to note is that Pāli is written in many different scripts. As the buddhist canon travelled, local people used either Indian scripts or switched to their own local scripts. For more on local scripts see here . But for now we are just interested in the Romanized Pali alphabet. This runs Vowels first, then consonants. as follows: a, ā, i, ī, u, ū, e, o (ṃ*) k, kh, g, gh, (ṅ) c, ch, j, jh, ñ ṭ, ṭh, ḍ, (ḍh), (ṇ) t, th, d, dh, n p, ph, b, bh, m y, r, l, (ḷ), (ḷh), v, s, h [Note: the letters in brackets have no entries in the dictionary.] Pali is a phonetic  language so each entry above represents a single sound. Every letter always has the same pronunciation regardless of its context, so no letter has more than one pronunciation, and no sounds are represented by more than one letter. As there are more sounds in Pāli than letters in the roman alphabet, to make distinctions, special

Velthuis to Diacritics converter & Pali Dictionary Lookup Tool

Convert to Unicode Type these Velthuis codes to convert into Pali unicode. aa → ā .m → ṃ ii → ī .t → ṭ uu → ū .d → ḍ "n → ṅ .n → ṇ